Friday, October 23, 2015

Thomas VS Katniss

In the book The Maze Runner it starts off when the main character Thomas awakes in an elevator in a state of oblivion. He doesn't remember anything or anyone. He then begins to hear strange and unfamiliar voices, once the voices sound uncomfortably close the elevator doors open. The bright light blinds Thomas and he is now greeted by other boys his age, he then finds out that he is now in a place known as the glades. The character Thomas reminds me a lot of Katniss from the Hunger Games. In the book The Hunger Games Katniss was placed into a situation where even though she was frightened, she was forced to rise up and put on a brave outward appearance so her family and friends wouldn’t be scared. Although Thomas has no recollection of his family or his former self, he still puts on a front of bravery so the other boys would not think he was weak. In the first few chapters it seems as if Thomas was selective of his friends. Once he learned a little about chuck he was eager to befriend him and stuck close to him. This reminds me of how Katniss was picky about who she trusted in the hunger games arena. She bonded with Rue and stuck close to her. One of the major comparisons in these books is when Thomas went to bed the night him and chuck really bonded. He moved his sleeping bag which showed that he must really trust chuck. Thomas was now trusting chuck enough to have him in his presence when he was in his most vulnerable state. This reminds me of when Katniss and Rue were officially allies, and they both slept up in the trees. In the hunger games the main purpose was to kill off the other contestants in the arena. When Katniss trusted Rue enough to have her sleep in a close radius, it showed that she was now opening up to Rue. At anytime Rue could have turned on Katniss and killed her, but Katniss trusted a stranger enough potentially have her life at risk. The last major comparison that I noticed between Thomas and Katniss was when they first witnessed Death. When Thomas was confronted by Ben in the graveyard, Ben began threatening Thomas with a knife. When Alby showed up with a bow to try and negotiate with Ben. He seemed to have aggravated the situation, ben continued to be unreasonable, Alby then shot an arrow which then killed Ben. Thomas was then in a state of shock after seeing this happen right in front of him. Which reminds me of when Katniss witnessed Rue's death right in front of her. In all reality Rue held more meaning to Katniss but the impact was still the same. She had to act fast and kill Marvel in order to avenge Rue. After witnessing death both characters had different reactions. Granted the deaths held different meaning for each of the characters. They both were still in shock, Katniss just had to make an impulse decision after. Since reading the first few chapters of The Maze Runner I have noticed several comparisons to The Hunger Games already. So now as I continue to read I am interested in seeing if I can find some more.


9 comments:

  1. I think these books both definitely compare to each other. I read both of them and saw many similar things. There is a huge similarity between the two books at the end on the Maze Runner also.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm happy that someone else was able to see the same similarities that I did. Now that you have mentioned the ending I am intrigued to see how it turns out. I have seen hunger games and have also read the book, so if maze runner ends like it I cant wait to see how it unfolds.

      Delete
  2. The books you have compared are very similar. They are both trying to stay alive and get away from where they are. I saw the movie of the books and they are books that I would like to read. Knowing that they are fighting to survive like in the old days seems interesting and makes me wanting to know more about the Maze Runner.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's what caught my attention. As soon as I read that Thomas was trying to stay alive, my brain immediately made the connection to Katniss. They also both do have a less modern feel to them. The fact that they both do exhibit B.C tactics when it comes to survival.

      Delete
  3. Juanita, I think that you found many similar aspects between Katniss and Thomas. While I have only read a part of the Maze Runner, I have read all three books of the Hunger Games series and I can see similarities and kind of see how Thomas is like Katniss in some ways, considering that I know how Katniss is. It was really eye-opening and this is the first comparison that I've seen of these two novels. I aim to just watch the movie of Maze Runner but you have me changing my mind.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jocelyn, I have been seeing the similarities poor in left and right. The more I read the more they hit me. The parts that I have read have me questioning if there are more to come. After hearing that the books end the same I cant wait to see if it follows the same story line as The Hunger Games.

      Delete
  4. I enjoy how you had two similar books and found many similarities.Katniss and Thomas seem to have similar aspects.Both are fighting for their lives in these books. They also seem to lean a bit on history a lot.

    ReplyDelete
  5. juanita, I think you nailed the aspects between Katniss and Thomas. in all honestly i have only watched the movie Maze Runner, and the hunger games. even tho they are two different stories completely i believe you did a great job compared the two together

    ReplyDelete
  6. juanita, I think you nailed the aspects between Katniss and Thomas. in all honestly i have only watched the movie Maze Runner, and the hunger games. even tho they are two different stories completely i believe you did a great job compared the two together

    ReplyDelete